Does ‘Reasonable Restriction’ mean Complete Prohibition?

Home / Legal Explainers / Citizen Rights & Constitution / Fundamental Rights / Freedom of Speech and Expression / Does ‘Reasonable Restriction’ mean Complete Prohibition?

If a state action completely prohibits an Article 19 right, the court should test the constitutional validity of that action based on the facts and circumstances of the case. In some cases, a total prohibition may be a reasonable restriction, while in others it may not.¹ For instance, a complete ban on carrying out dangerous trades or businesses, such as cultivation of drugs, or the sale of liquor may be considered a reasonable restriction. At the same time, a total prohibition on the sale or purchase of meat during a particular religious festival may not be considered reasonable.

Narendra Kumar v. Union of India, AIR 1960 SC 430 [↩]

Have a question you want to ask our legal experts?

Ask Nyaaya

Related Resources

Guide for Survivors of Sexual Harassment at the Workplace

This guide by Nyaaya and Ungender helps those who have faced sexual harassment at the workplace to navigate the legal process in such situations.

What does the law prohibit?

The law prohibits conducting sex selection or prenatal diagnostic procedures, determining and communicating the sex of the foetus, selling machines for sex determination and advertising sex determination facilities.